New Times,
New Thinking.

The Staggers

The latest comment and analysis from our writers

21 November

David Lammy’s balancing act

Donald Trump will test Labour’s new approach to China and Europe.

By George Eaton

“Shame on Putin!” As David Lammy sat in the chair of the UN Security Council for the first time, his voice reverberated through the ornate chamber. The Russian delegation had just vetoed a resolution calling for a ceasefire in Sudan where one of the world’s worst humanitarian crises is unfolding. Lammy assailed Putin for “pretending to be a partner of the Global South while condemning black Africans to further killing, further rape, further starvation”.  Hostility towards Putin’s Russia – a “mafia state” seeking to become a “mafia empire” in Lammy’s words – is one of the defining strands of UK foreign policy under Labour. This week saw British-made Storm Shadow missiles fired by Ukraine into Russia for the first time. During ...

20 November

The truth about the Allison Pearson free speech row

Should the police be visiting journalists over the tweets they send?

By Alison Phillips

More than a week after the arrival of police at the front door of the Telegraph columnist Allison Pearson regarding a tweet she had written in 2023, debate rumbles on. Was this a threat to free speech and an example of police overreach? Or was it a legitimate enquiry into the publication of content which may have had real-world consequences? In November 2023, Pearson posted a photograph of police officers posing next to two men of colour holding a Pakistani political party’s flag. The picture had no connection to any of the protests in the wake of the 7 October attacks and Israel’s response. In a caption she labelled the men “Jew haters”. The tweet was later deleted. On 10 November ...

19 November

Labour can no longer hide from the cost of Brexit

Weak growth and a Trump trade war could force the party to change its Europe policy.

By David Gauke

There is a hypothesis that I have set out before in these columns and now might be a good time to revisit it. The hypothesis is a simple one. Labour would fight the 2024 general election saying as little as possible about Brexit and its consequences but, having secured victory, the pressure would build for a more ambitious policy of moving closer to Europe. By the time we got to the next election in 2028 or 2029, I argued, Brexit would once again be a major issue. I was reminded of this when the governor of the Bank of England, Andrew Bailey, used his Mansion House speech last week to point out rather tentatively that “the changing trade relationship with the ...

18 November

Keir Starmer wants immigration control to be a Labour cause

The Prime Minister is seeking to redefine the politics of border security.

By George Eaton

Keir Starmer wants you to know that he cares about immigration. Last week he named border security – alongside economic growth – as his top priority when abroad. Yesterday he signalled that he favours Italian-style migration deals with third countries to reduce Channel crossings.  It’s tempting to view this renewed activity as a response to the Democrats’ electoral cataclysm. Illegal immigration across the US southern border – which reached a record high under Joe Biden – was one of the issues that doomed Kamala Harris.  But put this point to Labour figures and they note – with some justification – that they moved into this political space long ago. Indeed, Starmer’s former director of strategy Deborah Mattinson has complained that the Democrats ...

15 November

The left case against slavery reparations

Black Britain should not be chained to the scars of the past.

By Ralph Leonard

The notion that Britain, being a former European colonial power, owes reparations to those it formerly enslaved and colonised has now reached the top of government. At the recent Commonwealth summit in Samoa, it was agreed that the “time has come” for a conversation on reparatory justice, a joint statement the UK reluctantly also signed. It is the culmination of a campaign that dates to at least the early days of postcolonial theory. “Colonialism and imperialism have not settled their debt to us once they have withdrawn from our territories,” Frantz Fanon wrote in his 1961 book The Wretched of the Earth. “The wealth of the imperialist nations is also our wealth. Europe is literally the creation of the third ...

15 November

Labour will not win a war on the countryside

A Jeremy Clarkson-led farmers’ movement is a powerful enemy.

By Ian Watts

When the Chancellor sat down after delivering her first Budget speech, she probably didn’t expect to find herself in the crosshairs of Jeremy Clarkson. Never shy of miring himself in controversy, he has suggested that, by reducing the scope of agricultural inheritance tax relief, “Reeves and her politburo” have declared “all out-war on the countryside”. The more sober and much more powerful National Farmers’ Union (NFU) is no less incensed, and is also now campaigning strongly against what it dubs the “family farm tax”. A noisy tractor-led demonstration in central London is planned for next week, and some farmers’ groups are also threatening to block ports and withhold non-perishable produce to disrupt supermarket supplies. In another failure of communication, the government ...

15 November

Hollywood voyeurism at the Marilyn Monroe exhibition

A collection of the star’s possessions tries to make celebrity worship a feminist pursuit.

By Ella Dorn

The upside of idolising dead people is that you can go through their things. It’s not creepy – you’re an amateur historian, reconstructing the material culture of a lost age. With some luck, the whole pursuit will gain the cachet of a primordial religious ritual. Virtually every major star from Hollywood’s Golden Age is gone, and many of them have since been transmuted into transcendent icons. The things they touch and the places they visit become sacred by proximity. This doesn’t get any clearer than at “Marilyn: The Exhibition”, a rare showing of 250 of the actress’s most intimate possessions at an incongruous venue near London Bridge Station. There has never been anything like this before in Britain; it provides the ...

15 November

Who will be the next SNP leader?

Stephen Flynn’s decision to stand for Holyrood is another signal of his ambition.

By Chris Deerin

What does Stephen Flynn want? The decision by the SNP’s Westminster leader to put his name forward as a candidate for Holyrood 2026 is some kind of answer.  Flynn is, according to his colleagues, and based on the evidence of his own actions, fiercely ambitious. No crime, that. The idea that he intends to take a seat in Edinburgh and sit quietly on the backbenches is not one that holds much water.  He has already performed a form of regicide, effectively taking out Ian Blackford as Westminster leader in a coup a couple of years ago. He did so against the advice of a number of his fellow MPs, which only added to his reputation for ruthlessness.    Flynn is among three of his ...