New Times,
New Thinking.

The Staggers

The latest comment and analysis from our writers

3 days ago

Forget Mandelson, Starmer holds the key to the special relationship

Until Labour knows what it wants from the US, the diplomats don’t matter.

By Luke McGee

The appointment of Peter Mandelson – former cabinet minister under Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, and former EU trade commissioner – as ambassador to the US has divided opinion. Supporters commend him as an experienced heavyweight. While sceptics question his judgement (he called Donald Trump “a bully” in 2018) and his advocacy for closer ties with China (at odds with the position of the Trump administration). There are countless reasons to believe that he is not the right person for the job – not least when candidates with an established relationship with the new American right were eschewed for a politician with considerable baggage. It is, however, exceedingly rare that a diplomat’s character itself would damage a relationship between allies. Trump ...

4 days ago

The Waspi women were lied to

Their campaign became the tool of cynical politicians.

By Will Dunn

The “Waspi women” – a group of campaigners who have since 2015 argued for compensation for money they lost as a result of changes to the state pension age – were defeated this week. On Tuesday (17 December) the Work and Pensions Secretary, Liz Kendall, announced that the government would not be paying them any compensation, in spite of a recommendation from the parliamentary ombudsman that they should receive up to £2,950 each. For a government with almost no fiscal headroom and a desperate need to fix ailing public services, the £10.5bn cost of offering such compensation was simply unaffordable. The decision has been met with furious denunciations of betrayal and broken promises. But the real villains here are the people ...

4 days ago

Journalism films give me the ick

Victims are side lined, while hacks make unworthy heroes.

By Susie Goldsbrough

If you’re a journalist with a healthy sense of self-importance, you’ll love September 5. This dad-friendly and Oscar-tipped new thriller about the 1972 Munich Olympics hostage crisis makes a bunch of burly American sports reporters into heroes. “I know it may not feel like it but you did a hell of a job today,” the head of ABC Sport (Peter Sarsgaard in serial-killer specs) reassures his rookie producer. The producer blinks back at him in quite reasonable disbelief. The crisis he’s been reporting has just ended in a shoot-out: 11 Israelis, five Palestinians and one West German police officer are dead. But not to worry – the plucky fellas at ABC did one hell of a job catching it all on ...

6 days ago

Why aren’t the Greens doing better?

The party hasn’t made the most of an unpopular Labour government.

By George Eaton

Britons’ favourite ideology is environmentalism. That’s according to an illuminating poll published by YouGov last week (it was the preferred choice of 64 per cent). This isn’t reflective of a nation of Just Stop Oil sympathisers but one in which David Attenborough is a secular saint and the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds has 1.2 million members. Nevertheless, in a country of environmentalists, you might expect the Greens to be thriving (concern about climate change exceeds 50 per cent in every seat). True, at the general election, they enjoyed their best-ever result. The party won four MPs and finished second to Labour in 39 seats. It also now has more than 800 councillors (and stands to make major gains in next year’s ...

17 December

Labour’s gamble with local government

There is no proof that abolishing councils will work.

By Megan Kenyon

One evening in late August 2018, Northamptonshire County Council took the unprecedented decision to abolish itself. The council was drowning in debt and had been forced to take an axe to local services. Earlier that year it had become the first local authority in two decades to declare itself bankrupt. On the recommendation of Max Caller, the government’s chief council fixer who had been called in to conduct a review of the struggling authority, the only way to overcome Northamptonshire’s issues was to rip it all up and start from scratch. In 2021, Northamptonshire’s existing county council and seven districts ceased operating and were replaced by two new unitary authorities.Before this, Northamptonshire was run via a two-tier system, whereby larger ...

17 December

The reality of Ireland’s anti-Israel stance

The country has drawn a false equivalence with Northern Ireland and Palestine.

By Finn McRedmond

Ireland was the last country in the European Union to host an Israeli embassy. It is now, nearly 30 years later, the first to have one closed down. Ireland – self-appointed standard-bearer of the peaceniks – joins Iraq, Somalia, North Korea et al in having no Israeli diplomatic representation. Israel had repeatedly criticised Ireland for its reflexively anti-Israel disposition. When the Irish government announced on 11 December it would intervene in calling for the International Court of Justice to expand its definition of genocide (to incorporate Israeli action in the Gaza War), the Rubicon was crossed. Israel’s foreign minister Gideon Sa’ar explained that “Ireland’s extreme anti-Israel policy” had become overwhelming, that the “anti-Semitic actions and rhetoric that Ireland is taking against ...

17 December

Christmas can’t save the high street

Property owners, the pandemic and Black Friday have killed the town centre.

By Jonn Elledge

In Christmas films, a festive trip to the shops is a magical experience. Cheerful shoppers bustle down snowy streets, to reach the light and warmth of department stores packed with alluring presents. Convincingly real Santas dandle happy children on their knees, next to perfectly dressed trees. Christmas is a commercial business, sure, but it’s also bright and fun. That, though, is a fantasy American past, not the real British present, and a trip to most British high streets this Christmas is likely to present a rather different experience. Half-hearted light displays in concrete post-war shopping precincts. Soggy, grumpy people grumbling their way past derelict retail units and the boarded up ruins that once housed a Debenhams. The shops that are open ...

17 December

Kemi Badenoch needs to improve – and fast

The Conservative leader needs a clearer strategy and greater respect for her MPs.

By David Gauke

On 22 December, Kemi Badenoch will have reached a milestone. She will have exceeded the 49 days Liz Truss served as leader of the Conservative Party. Whatever the future holds, Badenoch can claim that she has not had the worst start or been the most short-lived of recent Tory leaders. Badenoch inherited a demoralised party that had suffered the worst election defeat in its history. It had won in 2019 by offering contradictory promises that it could not deliver to a broad coalition of supporters that could not be sustained.  Populist voters preferred the offer of Reform UK – uncontaminated by the experience of government – while pragmatists defected to Labour and the Liberal Democrats. Tactical voting and the widespread desire to ...