Registered user login:

Far right on the march

Brittany Peats

Published 19 November 2008

In the wake of the publication of BNP members list we focus on the rise of the far right in Europe particularly in Italy where racism has penetrated the public discourse

Xenophobia seems to be part and parcel of modern Italian politics

The publication of the British National Party's 10,000-strong membership list has once again shone the spotlight on the far right in the UK.

But it is in Europe that such organisations are causing gravest concern. A far-right Czech group tried to attack a Roma camp on Monday and Austria's two far-right groups together won almost a third of the vote in September's national election. And then there's Italy.

In April, the country gave the far-right party Lega Nord (the Northern League) an electoral shot in the arm. Romans chose a mayor who had once led a Neo-Fascist youth movement.

Immigrants are routinely scapegoated for rising crime - incorrectly blamed on a recent influx of people from the former Yugoslavia and northern Africa. This fear is increased as “the media amplifies crime when there are immigrants involved,” says Anna Bull, professor of Italian history at the University of Bath.

The government has been slow to respond to the changing ethnic make-up of the country. “There has been little discussion of multiculturalism” says her colleague, Professor Roger Eatwell, who adds and xenophobia is still rampant.

The Italian discrimination against the Roma people has a growing notoriety not least because it often continues with the backing, tacit or otherwise, of the government and legal system.

Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, whose campaign promised a clampdown on "Roma, clandestine immigrants and criminals," supports the mandatory fingerprinting of all Roma, including minors.

In March Italy's highest court found a mayor who believed that "all Gypsies were thieves" not guilty of racial discrimination. Many Roma camps outside of Rome and Naples have been razed.

Italy's state-sanctioned xenophobia – over half of Italians would like to see the Romas expelled from the country - was demonstrated by shocking photographs of Italians sunbathing just a few feet from the dead bodies of two drowned Roma girls.

Rome's far right mayor Gianni Alemanno made a promise to crack down on immigrants central to his campaign. At his inauguration, skinheads reportedly chanted “Duce. Duce,” in a direct link to Italy's dictator Fascist dictator Mussolini.

Upon entering office Alemanno instituted a 'Pact for Rome' which included the following directives: “Immediately activate procedure for the expulsion of 20,000 nomads and immigrants who have broken the law in Rome” and “Closure of illegal nomad camps, rigorous and effective checks on legal ones and their progressive elimination.” He also has said that it would be simplistic to consider fascism an "absolute evil".

Meanwhile, the Lega Nord, is playing its part. One of their leaders, Roberto Maroni - who serves as the interior minister - authored the Roma fingerprinting proposal and last week the party announced a plan to place a two-year ban on immigration.

The lack of long-established parties may make Italy more susceptible to extreme parties. “In most countries there are the same parties as there were 20, 30, 40 years ago. In Italy there are completely new parties since the 1990s” says Eatwell. “Personal identity with parties is very weak which leaves the country open to the possibility of radical change.”

The National Alliance party is generally acknowledged to be in position to take power after Berlusconi and his Forza Italia party. The Alliance party is the successor to the Italian Social Movement which grew out of Mussolini's fascist party.

The party has “made great strides in renouncing and denouncing fascism and the leader Gianfranco Fini has made the party more mainstream, centre-right though there are still elements of neo-fascists,” said Bull. Any moderate sentiments are generally absent in the rank and file members however.

The party differs from the Lega Nord in significant ways but they are united over their stance on immigration leading to speculation that the two parties could form a coalition.

Italian President Giorgio Napolitano spoke out last week against the anti-immigration sentiments embodied by the increasingly powerful extreme right. He said, "We need a climate of openness and appreciation towards foreigners who are Italian.” Maybe this indicates a turning point away from the support of the anti-immigrant far-right and instead towards the embrace of multiculturalism in Italy.

There doesn't seem to be much evidence of it elsewhere sadly.


Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

12 comments from readers

Ignazio
19 November 2008 at 12:29

"Last year Italy's highest court has ruled that discrimination against the Roma is legal because "all Gypsies were thieves.”"

Please post some robust evidence of this UNACCEPTABLE claim. I'm not savvy in court matters, but I won't believe this without some evidence. Not backed up, this claim is downright insulting. To cite your last statement, sadly I don't see a lot of evidence backing your attack on Italian institutions. While I share your opinion of the Lega Nord, I highly doubt it represents half the Italians. don't let Bossi's big mouth fool you into believing what he says.

Ignazio

Bhatti
19 November 2008 at 12:37

" This fear is increased as “the media amplifies crime when there are immigrants involved,” says Anna Bull, professor of Italian history at the University of Bath."

Just like in the UK

Brittany Peats
19 November 2008 at 13:45

Here are two links regarding the court's ruling about the Roma people:

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/europe/article42...

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/jul/01/italy

Ignazio
19 November 2008 at 14:34

Quoting from one of the links:

"The court of cassation decided this did not show Tosi was a racist, but that he had "a deep aversion [to Roma] that was not determined by the Gypsy nature of the people discriminated against, but by the fact that all the Gypsies were thieves". His dislike of them was "not therefore based on a notion of superiority or racial hatred, but on racial prejudice". The judges scrapped the two-month jail sentences and ordered that the case be reheard."

This does NOT say the Cassazione said it's ok to discriminate, it says that the court ruled that what's been proved is racial prejudice and not racial hatred, and has ordered the case to be reopen, which means a new sentence might be inflicted on the defendant. In order to say "it's ok to discriminate" the Court should have said that there was no crime or misconduct, and in that case there would be no new hearing. The ruling of the Court has not been received favorably by many who wanted a stronger position against racism, but it doesn't legitimate racist behavior. Personally, I would have liked the guy banned from public service, but still the Court is not granting impunity for hate crimes.

Ignazio

Brittany Peats
19 November 2008 at 16:56

I have corrected the article.

Ignazio
19 November 2008 at 17:04

Thanks a lot, appreciated.

Ignazio

marco
20 November 2008 at 12:23

First of all I would like to thank Ignazio for the very well put critique to the the way the Cassazione decision was described in the above article.

What I would like to add is my concern of the "right" being able to make out a political platform out of genuine concerns about management of the Roma camps and everything that goes with it.

If you go to Rome, or the rest of Italy for that matter, you will realize that certain problems will not be solved by merely shutting your eyes and pretending that all is well. It isn't.

I want the Roma kids to be able to go to school and not to spend their days begging in the street, same goes for the women.

They need to be integrated; I know, integration is a horrible word, but reality has never been pleasant.

The "left" in italy has never been able to do anything about it.

Only words and slogans, and, thanks to this lack of skills and imagination the right has taken up the issue to their own benefit.

We need to be more practical and less PC in order to gain people's votes.

Any British person looking at a Roman camp would be horrified simply because that would not be permitted in England.

So my reccomendation is; let us stop being so bloody Politically Correct and let's get down to business if we want people's vote to redirect again toward the left.

FreedomLand
20 November 2008 at 15:02

Sad that the latest genetic discoveries that we are all so closely related upon this planet have been so utterly ignored by the self-righteous and the prejudiced. Thus such racism is as obscene as considering one's group to be "the chosen ones" of some imaginary deity in one's own image to the exclusion of all others as the religious crazies still maintain.

But didn't someone there try to re-establish the sanctimonious hypocrisy of the Byzantine empire opposing the supposedly evil Turks a mere two years ago?

mitchy
21 November 2008 at 16:32

Heh! There's fun to be had with that leaked BNP member's list, sure as sure...

FreedomLand
22 November 2008 at 04:55

#mitchy - "..that leaked BNP member's list, sure as sure..."

Has already gone as far as Australia - Leaked list outs Aussie fascist supporters http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2008/11/21/1226770697713.h...

lolilol
22 November 2008 at 12:02

I feel sorry for the Rom, because they are foreign like me, but to be honest, I doubt if their condition will improve in the foreseeable future. I live in the south of Italy - provincia di caserta - and amazingly enough, Bossi has many supporters down here. I'd say that rascism is still a big problem, but maybe that's to be expected in an area where there's high unemployment - crime is one of the biggest employers. Fear of the unknown is exploited by both left and right, and above all, in my opinion, Italy hasn't been a unified country long enough for people to really feel like citizens. Where I live you're a 'foreigner' even if you come from the next county or village even. I work in a town called Aversa, the people of Caserta refer to the inhabitants of this town as criminals, and the people of my village won't even eat in a local restuarant owned by an Aversan, and those that do are branded 'criminals' by the rumour-mongers. (I've eaten there, good food, nice ambience, never too crowded ;-) )

anne warren
24 November 2008 at 16:48

Agree with the University professor who stated there was “There has been little discussion of multiculturalism and xenophobia is still rampant", Italy's appalling attitude to the Rom is one more example of its attitude to foreigners and its refusal to comply with EU laws and principles - see the various verdicts "guilty of discrimination on the grounds of nationality " as directed against University Foreign Language Lecturers.

As far as regards the growth of a Neo-Fascist movement - Right wing "thug squads" beat up "different" looking individuals on a daily basis, particularly in the big cities, and have even recently invaded the state

TV (RAI) offices in Rome (as they objected to the content of a programme) and the headquarters of the left wing (CGIL) trade union.

As the EU seems very reluctant to bring any pressure to bear, presumably the situation suits it. And to forestall any arguments along the lines of the people get the government they vote for please have a look at "Silvio Berlusconi: Yes, yes, yes, Prime Minister"

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/europe/article51...

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

Read More

Vote!

Should Britain now join the euro?