Registered user login:

The hell of Bolzaneto

Monica Frassoni

Published 17 July 2008

Leading Italian Green politician Monica Frassoni on the brutality of Italian police at the Genoa G8 and how victims will never get justice in the home of the mafia

After more than 180 sessions, involving 360 witnesses, sentences for the 2001 Genoa police brutality against G8 demonstrators were announced this week.

Of the 46 accused - civil, military and prison police - 30 were declared not guilty. The remaining 16 including police and prison officers were sentenced to minor punishments.

So what happenen in the dark hours on the 21st to 22nd July 2001 in the Bolzaneto barracks where those arrested were taken?

Hell, as the public prosecutor described it, explicitly stating that in Bolzaneto that night torture was practised and the most elementary human rights were brutally violated.

The death of one of the young demonstrators, Carlo Giuliani, the unsually wild beatings, the pictures shown on TVs had a strong impact on Italian and European public opinion in the summer of 2001.

After four years, in October 2005, finally, the trial started and considering that the Italian justice allows two appeal stages, more years will have to go by before the formal final judgement.

All analysts agree that no-one will ever spend one single day in jail, nor pay a single euro in damages for the violence which injured nearly 300 injured people and left some permanently traumatised.

The heaviest sentence was five years in jail for the police officer responsible for the Bolzaneto site - a term that will expire in January 2009 thanks to new laws by the latest Berlusconi government and because of the eternal time that trials take in Italy means the statute of limitations will kick in.

The police officer in question, Antonio Biagio Gugliotta, invented the swan position - the detainees had to stand for up to one full night and day facing a wall, with open legs and arms up. They were repeatedly hit kicked and insulted and obliged to chant Uno, due, tre, viva Pinochet! or the more Mussolini
tasting Duce! Duce!

Mind you, Italian institutions know how to be Scandinavian and operate efficiently. But the malfunctiong Italian judiciary has no chance in a country where one of the most successful exports is called the mafia.

Alas, the rule of law is still not one of Italy’s strong points.


Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

9 comments from readers

Pencils
17 July 2008 at 21:02

Another good reason for leaving the EU. If Italy is allowed in it, we shouldn't touch it with a barge-pole.

Carl Packman
18 July 2008 at 02:13

I agree with the last comment

Viscount Firm
18 July 2008 at 09:12

And I don't!

Clive
18 July 2008 at 10:19

Let's stop dreaming about 'coming out'; it will not and cannot happen - at least in the manner most all of us want. Successive governments are willingly locked into the Project and look how Brown read the Public opposition to the EU by denying a referendum. There is too little democracy and too much dictatorship underpinning the EU to allow mere disorganised citizens to topple it. No more choice; collapse will have to wait for another route.

gnuneo
18 July 2008 at 16:55

EU or downing st? Both as bad as each other.

willoyen
18 July 2008 at 19:14

Oh the poor British, having to associate with Italians, Mafiosi the lot, in the vile EU! Oh, god, those violent Italians! Well, I am a regular visitor to Italy, and the sense of security there is palpable, everywhere, thanks not least to a constant police presence, not to mention the Carabinieri. Streets, car parks, seaside promenades, tourist spots, cafés, bars, even train stations and trains, are all patrolled or visited conspicuously. Italy has the lowest level of violence and homicide in Europe, (vide The Economist, last week). The events in Genoa were shocking indeed. Especially to the unspotted Brits! But who was called to account for the murder of de Menezes? Well, it was just a Health and Safety offence! And the shooting of the Muslim suspect in Forest Gate. Not to mention others. There will always be abuse, from boys being boys, and very nasty boys, in the aggressive professions, the police and army. But the Brits have the impudence to criticize Italy?! For 30 years Britain has been virtually un-policed, and now we suffer! Police officers, (no longer mere policemen), are far too lofty and exalted to actually deign to appear in the streets. Officers and gentlemen don’t go on the beat. So we have the horror of violent Britain, now the most violent country in the western world, not just Europe (same source). Britain is the basket case. I should think the Italians and others would welcome the departure from the EU which so many Brits (also the most ignorant about the EU and its institutions) are always so tiresomely, nauseatingly threatening. Viva Italia!

gnuneo
18 July 2008 at 19:58

so in italy there are police *everywhere* in public? Every street corner, every park, every train station, every cafe and bar?

has somebody gone and cloned mussolini?? Are we supposed to regard this as a good model for a society??

there are grave faults in British society, and the de menezes murder is just one example, but to imagine our becoming a literal police-state will improve matters is breathtaking!

what we need is a good civil society, citizens young and old who know they are part of a Good society that will take care of them, prod them when it is needed, that the society is concerned with ALL of us, not the extremely few living in guilded palaces, royalty or not.

maybe i'm just an old English Radical, maybe i'm a naive un-marxist Evolutionist, or maybe i just don't believe making 30% of the population into police officers and State spies is beneficial for a country.

especially when the article you are supposed to be commenting on is a graphic illustration of what happens when police officers believe they are 'above the Law' themselves, and go to work like Inquisitors at Guantanamo Bay.

Johnboy
19 July 2008 at 18:08

'But the Brits have the impudence to criticize Italy?! '

Willoyen, the author of this article is an Italian not a Brit. The article is not a heavy criticism anyway, it just refers to the police brutality at Genoa and the fact that the Italian legal system is a mess.

willoyen
19 July 2008 at 19:54

thanks Johnboy. I appreciate your sympathetic comment. But I my post was not so much a reaction to Monica Frassoni's article, as to the usual knee-jerk British response as manifested in the first comments above.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

Read More

Vote!

Is this the worst economic situation for 60 years?